I first became aware of the phenomenon known as opting out in 2003 when Lisa Belkin wrote her much debated New York Times article ‘The Opt Out Revolution’. The article wasn’t going to become significant in my life until years later when I started researching opting out for my PhD, but I did read it at the time and I remember that it made an impression. There were many in things that spoke to me in the article as I was grappling with whether or not the career I was pursuing really was what I wanted to be doing. But one thing in particular left an impression.
For the article, Lisa Belkin had interviewed women who had opted out of so-called successful careers to become stay-at-home moms. One woman she had talked to said that although she had what was considered a successful career before opting out, she didn’t feel it gave her a successful life. In other words, she was successful in all the ways we traditionally view success, but it didn’t make her feel particularly successful.
So, what is success? When you think of the word successful, what do you see?
In research we differentiate between objective and subjective measures of success. Objective measures are what we typically think of as being successful in society: status, power, salary, title…. things that the women in Belkin’s article all had before they opted out. I find that a lot of people pursue this type of success without questioning it. After all, many of us are indoctrinated to believe that this is something worthy of pursuit as it is highly valued in society.
So, what happens when you start to question it? And should more of us question it?
These are questions I grapple with in my work.
For many people who opt out of so-called successful careers, it isn’t until something happens in their life, that makes pursuing that career untenable, that they start to really question it in earnest. They experience something that provides them with the insight that they just can’t go on the way they have. It is only after having that insight that they really start to think about what it means to be successful and what success means to them.
Opting out is a time of soul searching. It can be very confusing because all of a sudden you start to question your choices and the things that you have taken for granted. You start to think about what is really important to you, and it is this process that helps you realize how you want to live your life and what you are and aren’t willing to give up for your career or for anything else.
It is in this moment you start to define what success means to you.
A question I sometimes get from other researchers is why I only look at success stories. They wonder about the legitimacy of my research since they think my data set only consists stories that have led to happy endings.
Well they are wrong; all the narratives I have collected are certainly not success stories. But they are also on to something because a feeling of success is kind of symptomatic of opting out and in. That is, if you have spent a lot of time thinking about what is important to you, and if you then opt in to a lifestyle where you can live and work according to those values, you will invariably feel successful, whether or not you are successful according to traditional or objective measures.
These are the so-called subjective measures or definitions of success, and they vary from person to person. What is important to me may not be important to you, which means that I might feel successful even though it doesn’t seem that way to you. I might not have a fancy title, but maybe I’m really making a difference in a lot people’s lives. I may not have a high salary, but maybe I have enough to focus on something that feels really meaningful to me. You catch my drift.
When you opt out to do things on your own terms, people will often question your choices, especially if it looks to them that you are throwing your career or life away. This is part of the price of breaking social norms. But that’s okay. Maybe opting out of something that is traditionally seen as successful is the right thing for you even if it isn’t for them. Maybe you’ve created your own definitions of success that you want to live by. Or maybe the idea of success is just unimportant to you. Whatever you want to do, do it because it is right for you.
We attach so much value to the concept of success in our society. But what is success anyway? What is it to you?
This blog post is inspired by a new book I’m working on: 12 Things to Consider when Opting Out